Distant Still - Trios for violin, horn and piano
21 November 2011
American Record Guide
Kil Patrick
The
presence of Brahms and Ligeti are felt whenever
the topic is horn trios, but these Danish
composers from three generations seem
intent on forging their own paths. The three-movement,
15-minute Near Still Distant Still
(2005), by Pelle Gudmundsen-Holmgreen (b
1932), is spare and strange. I consists of tentative violin
gestures with occasional meek utterances
by horn and piano. After that odd introduction,
the brief and angry II is something of a
relief. Its quiet ending leads to a strange,
eerie III with questioning instrumental lines
and occasional spoken sounds and words
("yeah?") that raise still more questions. The
big piece is the four-movement, 27- minute
Horn Trio (1998) by Poul Ruders (b 1949),
whose harmonies are atonal and melodic gestures
are abstract.
I (Alpha) has long, connected
horn and violin lines, sporadic piano
comments, and a few unisons that seem like
oases. A little perpetual-motion II (Jewel) has
multiphonics by the horn player. III (Turning
Point) is a long, impressive horn cadenza
with eerie pitch-bending and sympathetic vibration
in the piano strings. IV (Omega)
is a maniacal, high-energy finale where
the musicians first vie for supremacy, then
return to the quiet tracery of I. The
19-minute Horn Trio (2007) by Soren Eichberg
(b 1973) bears some kinship with the one
by Brahms. The instruments speak a common (often
quite tonal) language and seem to work
toward a common goal. Although there are
strange moments, as well as ones so intense
that Brahms would find them incomprehensible, this
is a fascinating and powerful piece. Potent
playing by violinist Christina Arstrand
(Danish National Symphony), horn player
Jakob Keiting (Copenhagen Philharmonic), and
pianist Per Salo.